Showing posts with label Pakistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pakistan. Show all posts

Friday, July 25, 2025

Operation Sindoor: Fire, Fallout, and the Fast-Turning Doctrine of Indian Strategy

When the Pahalgam terrorist attack shook the country in May 2025, leaving 26 innocent lives lost, something inside India seemed to snap — not in anger, but in clarity. What followed wasn’t just retaliation; it was a playbook rewritten in real-time.

Operation Sindoor unfolded like a well-scoped mission with modern military teeth. As I watched this story unfold — as a citizen, not a general — I was reminded of two strikingly different lenses: Christine Fair’s unrelenting diagnosis of the Pakistan Army, and James Warden’s strategy bible, Winning in Fast Times. One exposes the permanent dysfunction across the border. The other offers a framework that, perhaps for the first time, India was now starting to follow.

Fast Strategy with Purpose: “Begin with the End in Mind”

James Warden speaks of organizations that win by starting with clarity — not just reacting, but setting a deliberate course. Operation Sindoor wasn’t a knee-jerk response. It was surgical, multi-phased, and clear in its goals: dismantle terror camps across Bahawalpur, Kotli, Muzaffarabad, and Muridke; neutralize Pakistan’s offensive launchpads; and redefine deterrence.

There was no public over dramatization. No premature chest-thumping. Just intent, action, and message.

Unified Command: When All Arms Move as One

Another core tenet from Winning in Fast Times is about “cross-functional alignment” — and India, long mired in bureaucratic inertia, finally seemed to move with a unified spine. Reports across platforms like PIB and Times of India revealed how:

  • The Air Force led preemptive strikes with satellite-guided munitions.

  • The Indian Navy launched deterrent operations in the Arabian Sea within 96 hours of the attack.

  • The Army mobilized along sensitive LoC zones, ensuring no vulnerability was left exposed.

It was jointness at scale — something India’s forces have often aspired to but seldom executed with such speed and cohesion.

The Pakistan Army: Playing by a Different Rulebook

To understand the other side, we go to Christine Fair’s Fighting to the End, where she argues that the Pakistan Army is designed not to win, but to sustain conflict eternally with India. She outlines a chilling truth: the Army doesn't fear tactical losses, because it thrives on ideological survival.

From that lens, even as Pakistani airbases and terror camps lay in ruins, the GHQ in Rawalpindi saw opportunity — to consolidate internal power, to reinforce the "India threat" narrative, and to justify future militarization.

This is what makes Pakistan uniquely dangerous. Fair makes it clear — peace is not the Pakistan Army’s goal; endurance is.

Speed as Strategy: Agility Over Doctrine

Warden’s insights hit home here. India’s past responses were sluggish, over-cautious, and telegraphed. Operation Sindoor moved with operational agility:

  • From intel to strike in under 72 hours.

  • From diplomacy to deployment without media fanfare.

  • From localized retaliation to deep strike doctrine, 100km inside Pakistani territory.

India is no longer playing checkers on Pakistan’s board. It’s flipping the board and setting its own pace.

But at What Cost?

This clarity, this agility, came at a price. In both Indian and Pakistan side of Kashmir, 43 civilian deaths were reported. Displacement. Fear. Loss.

Christine Fair reminds us: the Pakistani Army may be the architect of endless hostility, but ordinary civilians bear the brunt. And Warden warns: speed without system can spiral. The key is not just to act quickly, but to ensure every fast move contributes to a long-term strategic posture.

Political and Strategic Takeaways

For India:

  • Strategic Autonomy Strengthened: A clear signal to both adversaries and allies — India acts on its own terms.

  • Public Morale and Unity: Political differences faded temporarily. Public sentiment was firmly behind the armed forces.

  • Credibility Reinforced: Not just militarily, but diplomatically — restraint was balanced with resolve.

Yet India must now prepare for the next act — a possible asymmetric retaliation, or cyber and proxy warfare. Fast doesn’t mean finished.

For Pakistan:

  • Military Setbacks: Real assets were lost — airfields damaged, training camps neutralized.

  • Narrative Recovery: Despite these, the Pakistan Army will likely use this moment to ask for more resources and clamp further on civilian control — exactly what Fair has chronicled.

  • International Isolation: Even old allies were muted. The world is tiring of the “plausible deniability” doctrine.

Final Thought: When Doctrine Meets Will

Operation Sindoor wasn’t just a military operation. It was a strategic pivot — a living manifestation of James Warden’s philosophy: “Be clear, be fast, be aligned.”

And yet, Christine Fair’s cold realism reminds us that India isn’t playing against an opponent looking to win. It’s playing against one looking to never stop playing.

To succeed in this dangerous neighborhood, India will need more than just fast times. It will need smart endurance, institutional reform, and a plan beyond the next strike.

Sindoor may be over. But the doctrine it awakened? That’s just beginning.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Seed makes Jungle

There is nothing called good or bad, thinking makes it so. I think what this has done is put the responsibility on the people who analyze and comment and not on the doer. Good Taliban and Bad Taliban, Good business practice and bad business practice, Migration of Jobs to the developing economy to unemployment in the very recession stuck developed economy. There are different views on each side of the story making it good for one and bad for other. I will leave this debate for some other day. What is for sure all this mentioned above were once the seed before becoming a dense jungle of thoughts, processes, people, culture and practices.

Let’s see something from the story of now famous son of a school teacher, a part from his biography “He was the second son of a school teacher. When he was 16 years old, he moved to Aden, Yemen. Initially, he worked as a dispatch clerk with A. Besse & Co. Two years later A. Besse & Co. became the distributors for Shell products and he was promoted to manage the company’s oil-filling station at the port of Aden...”. The biography continues “Yemini administration realized that their main unit of currency, the Rial, was disappearing fast. Upon launching an investigation, they realized that a lot of Rials were being routed to the Port City of Aden. It was found that a young man in his twenties was placing unlimited buy orders for Yemini Rials. During those days, the Yemini Rial was made of pure silver coins and was in much demand at the London Bullion Exchange. Young man bought the Rials, melted them into pure silver and sold it to the bullion traders in London. During the latter part of his life, while talking to reporters, it is believed that he said “The margins were small but it was money for jam. After three months, it was stopped. But I made a few lakhs. In short, I was a manipulator. A very good manipulator. But I don’t believe in not taking opportunities.”. His most famous quotes are “You do not require an invitation to make profits” and the one that I like the most is “Think fast, Think big, Think ahead, ideas are no one’s monopoly”. So what was the seed? Probably the appetite to do big and the fuel came from the silver in Rials. Today those seeds have graduated in jungles (divided into two and both are growing) I must say. There were tons of allegation on his business practices but so it be the seed kept on getting its fuel and it grew to a tree and then to a jungle.

Some love it, some envy, some get there daily bread and some are simply proud of it. I am talking of what “Bangalore” stands for today, it again started with a small seed. Mysore Maharaja wanted electricity for Kolar gold mines(KGF), he did set up a hydroelectricity plant, the wires were crossing Bangalore and they decided to replace the oil/gas street lights with the electric one with the surplus electric production. This made Bangalore to be the first city in the country to have electricity. This proved to be an important resource for fuelling scientific, academic, research and technology around Bangalore. Finally when the India’s time came in the flat wired world it was actually Bangalore which was ready to grab this opportunity. Surely the small seed planted by the Maharaja has grown into a full-fledged jungle.

There was another seed sown way back in 1947. The formation of Pakistan was on the non proved theory of its founders that Hindus and Muslims cannot stay together in peace. They thought that the religion they represent will be in danger. Sometime I see merit in the famous communist quote “religion is the opium of masses”. If there is tasks unachievable just add religious mix and there will be a lot of buyer for that. A famous columnist and writer comments in his Sunday column “The two strands within Pakistan's DNA began to slowly split its personality. The father of the nation, Mohammed Ali Jinnah, thought he had produced a child in his own image, but his secular prescription was soon suppressed. His ideas were buried at his funeral. His heirs began to concede space to mullahs like Maulana Maudoodi who asked, in essence, that if Pakistan had been created to defend Islam, then who would be its best guardians?” So thus started the religious bias which was further fuelled by the politicians and the dictators the country had from time to time. You should not ride a tiger as the tiger do not know how to help you in dismounting; all it knows is to have a morsel. Hence nobody in Pakistan dared to dismount it and they continue. I was hearing a famous Pakistani cricketer turned politician for his reason on “sariat” (Islamic laws) implemented in one of the province (Swat), he said that it was implemented because there was no remedy to the normal people for their legal woes and this is the most efficient way to provide them this facility, it was there long term demand and the Government just conceded. I some time pity the people appearing to defend Pakistan in the Indian television from the Pakistani side. It is left best to the readers to estimate where this country is heading. The columnist concluded his column with “I had a previously arranged speaking engagement at a university in Delhi before largely Muslim students. I began with the suggestion that every Indian Muslim should offer a special, public prayer of thanks to the Almighty Allah for His extraordinary benevolence - for the mercy He had shown by preventing us from ending up in Pakistan in 1947. The suggestion was received with startled amusement, instinctive applause and a palpable sense of sheer relief.” All I have to say is see the seed and its growing as a jungle .

Today, we all in our daily life sow a seed on quite a regular basis. It can be that of a thought in oneself, one that is in your work place, one in your home or your children, one in your community, state, country, world and so on and so forth. It is good to watch out these seeds, you never know which seed can survive and get enough fertilization to become a jungle. For seeds do not know good or bad they only know to grow and multiply albeit it gets its fertilization.